How Procurement Really Decides Who Wins the Bid

When suppliers hear they’ve lost a bid, the most common reactions are:

• “We had the best price!”

• “Our solution was a perfect fit!”

• “We’ve worked with them before — what happened?”

The truth is, procurement decisions are rarely about a single factor. Behind every award decision — whether it’s a formal RFP or an informal quote — is a structured evaluation based on multiple weighted categories.

In this article, I’m pulling back the curtain on what those categories are and how procurement teams actually make decisions. This is the scoring playbook you wish you had before you submitted your last bid.

The 3–4 Core Scoring Criteria You Must Understand

Most procurement evaluations — especially formal ones — revolve around a few key categories:

1️⃣ Price — But It’s Not Everything

Price always matters — but it’s almost never the deciding factor by itself. Procurement teams look at:

• Total cost of ownership (TCO)

• Clarity and completeness of pricing

• Payment terms and conditions

• Scalability of pricing over time

If your price is the lowest but your terms are vague or your cost model looks risky, your score drops. Procurement wants value, not just a cheap number.

Your Move:
☑ Present your price in the exact format they ask for.
☑ Be transparent — no hidden fees or gotchas.
☑ Highlight how your pricing offers long-term value, not just a quick win.

2️⃣ Technical Fit — Do You Solve the Right Problem?

Your offering might be excellent — but if it doesn’t match the stated requirements, you’re out. Procurement teams score technical fit based on:

• How well your solution meets the scope

• Alignment with the technical or functional specs

• Proof of capabilities (case studies, demos, certifications)

3️⃣ Risk — How Confident Are They in You?

Procurement lives and dies on risk management. Even a perfect offer can lose if the buyer perceives you as a risk. They’ll evaluate:

• Your financial stability

• Your past performance and client references

• Delivery timelines and guarantees

• Compliance with regulations and standards

Your Move:
☑ Proactively address potential concerns.
☑ Offer clear risk mitigation plans.
☑ Provide verifiable references and success stories.

4️⃣ Value-Added — The Hidden Tie-Breaker

Sometimes two bids score almost identically. The winner? The one who offered something more.

Value-added criteria include:

• Innovation or unique approaches

• Enhanced support or training

• Flexibility in partnership

• Insights beyond the scope of the project

Your Move:
☑ Without overcomplicating, highlight what makes you different.
☑ Frame your extras in terms of customer benefit — not fluff.
☑ Offer ideas or support that show you’re invested in their success.

What This Means for You

Winning procurement decisions aren’t about guessing. They’re about aligning your proposal with how procurement actually scores:
✅ Be competitive on price — but show value.
✅ Nail the technical fit with tailored responses.
✅ Eliminate risk and inspire confidence.
✅ Bring something extra that tips the scales.

If you stop focusing on just one factor and start addressing all the key scoring categories, you’ll win more — and lose a lot fewer deals for reasons that never made sense.

Want More Insider Tips?
Subscribe to our newsletter and get weekly insights on how procurement really works — straight from the buyer’s side of the table.